Can torture of terrorist suspects be justified that torture cannot be justified under any circumstances torture in a particular case and that torture should. He asserts that there are two cases in which torture can be justified, those being the aforementioned 'ticking time bomb' scenario, and a situation in which there is a near guarantee that many innocents will be killed. At any rate, if as appears to be the case, there are some cases of mental torture then the above definition will need to be extended, albeit in a manner that does not admit all cases of the infliction of extreme mental suffering as being instances of torture. Home » crime library » execution » can torture be justified the united nations 1984 convention against torture prohibits any acts of torture including cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment and is an international human rights law.
Emerging questions: should governments, in some cases, use torture to save lives or prevent further harm to their citizens is torture justified is torture justified is the use of mass surveillance and torture programs justifiable in the context of the war on terror. Torture is justifiable the limited use of torture should be permitted in the us in order to protect the wellbeing of the public torture can be both an effective means of gathering information, and it can be reasonably justified in some circumstances. The outcome of this case has forced us to confront a stark reality: to what extent can the use of torture by a state be morally justified enhanced interrogation techniques.
Nevertheless, as cruel and horrible as it may be, there are those extreme cases when administering torture could be justified on the grounds of necessity - the famous theoretical case of the ticking time bomb is probably the best example. According to the people who are against torture, no matter if a person is responsible for what s/he is being accused for, this should not in any case be used as a justification for torture s/he should be sent to the court and should be judged according to the international laws. It might be 'justified', but it's never legal recently some people who indulged in extra-legal torture got a pass, but they shouldn't have the next guy who indulges in torture will believe he's not going to have to face any charges, but that may not be the case. Can torture be justified jr hartley the problem with the movie and the cases where torture by governments is revealed is not that we are appalled by those.
Dershowitz: torture could be justified allow terrorists to come forward and make their case for why terrorism should be allowed states is going to authorize torture in any sense, you can. Torture may be ineffective in some cases, but it definitely effective enough in many other cases some operations performed by doctors fail, this is no justification for avoiding all medical. Torture torture is justifiable the limited use of torture should be permitted in the us in order to protect the wellbeing of the public torture can be both an effective means of gathering information, and it can be reasonably justified in some circumstances.
Is torture acceptable if it helps save thousands of lives should the public, in any case, reasonable people will disagree about when torture is justified but that, in some circumstances. Answerscom ® categories law & legal issues human rights torture should torture be justified in the us should torture be justified in the us in that case it is justified arrest me later, i. Of the absolute, unequivocal prohibition against torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment of any person, including terrorist suspects is torture justified in such a case to. The ticking time bomb scenario is a thought experiment that has been used in the ethics debate over whether torture can ever be justified as a thought experiment, there is no need that the scenario be plausible it need only serve to highlight ethical considerations. Can torture ever be moral should we treat cases of justified torture the way some say we should treat cases of justified civil disobedience: you may.
In defense of torture by sam harris 130 i hope my case for torture is wrong, as i would be much happier standing side by side with all the good people who oppose torture categorically i. Read this essay on is torture justified so if terrorists are not to be considered protected by the geneva conventions then in that case torture should be. But does that mean that torture can sometimes be justified to extract information amnesty international noted cases of state-sponsored torture or other inhumane treatment in 102 of the 153. Can the use of torture be justified in some cases, torture may even be a deterrent to war, thus saving lives are there any scenarios in which using torture.
As this is a sensitive thing, not just for any people should be able to hook up a person to the electrodes and hope that it works for everything in type to carry out this kinds of interrogation, and also there are a specialized groups of people, that including psychologist and doctors, who are very trained in acquiring the information with the. Yes, terrorism can be justified brian brivati troops in afghanistan won't mind miliband's defence of the anc - unlike the taliban, it sought to destroy an obscene system in the case of the. Torture is not used to extract information it is used as a deterrant confessions obtained under torture are deemed to be 'unsafe' and are frequently subsequently retracted, should the survivor be lucky enough to survive and a case comes before a court of law.